WASHINGTON: A federal judge ruled that Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) can access the Department of Education’s data. This decision comes despite privacy concerns raised by a group of students receiving financial aid through government programs.
The students had requested an emergency injunction to prevent DOGE from accessing their personal data, arguing that their privacy could be at risk. They sought intervention from Judge Randy Moss of the DC District Court, hoping to halt DOGE’s access until further investigations could be conducted. However, Judge Moss dismissed the request, stating that the students had not demonstrated how they were being harmed by DOGE’s access at this time.
Privacy Concerns
The students’ lawsuit highlighted the potential risks to their personal information, as DOGE affiliates work with government systems. They feared that their financial data, which is sensitive and private, could be exposed. Despite these concerns, Moss concluded that violations of privacy law were not evident at this moment. He noted that the students could return to court later if their data was improperly disclosed.
This ruling marks the third recent court decision rejecting emergency requests to limit DOGE’s access to sensitive government data. The cases have mainly focused on privacy issues and whether DOGE’s involvement could lead to violations of privacy laws.
Court Rulings
In his ruling, Moss emphasized that the students’ legal action was premature since no proven harm had occurred yet. He also explained that the students could seek financial compensation if their data was ever disclosed without authorization in the future.
The court’s decision follows a series of similar rulings that have allowed DOGE to proceed with its work within executive branch agencies. Judges in Washington, DC, have not yet found sufficient grounds to block DOGE’s data access or its operations in the government.
 Other court decisions have addressed DOGE’s access to data at the Labor Department, the Department of Health and Human Services, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
Emergency Lawsuits
The lawsuits targeting DOGE have been consistent in their claims of privacy violations, but courts have repeatedly sided with DOGE. Critics argue that DOGE’s access to sensitive data poses a serious risk to privacy. However, the court’s stance has been that there is insufficient evidence of harm at this point to warrant an emergency intervention.
The ruling is significant because it further establishes the legality of DOGE’s current operations. Even with the ongoing concerns over privacy, the courts have been unwilling to take immediate action against DOGE. This has led to increased attention on the relationship between government agencies and Musk’s department.
Wider Legal Impact
Earlier in the day, Judge Moss also declined to block Musk’s use of a server to send mass emails to government employees. This ruling, which involved the use of technology for communication within federal agencies, further supports the notion that DOGE’s influence and activities in government operations remain largely uncontested.
This case also follows a series of previous rulings in which judges found no compelling reason to restrict DOGE’s work within federal agencies. Most notably, decisions involving the Department of Labor and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau did not result in limitations on DOGE’s access to government data.
Future Legal Battles
As these lawsuits against DOGE continue, new legal challenges are emerging. Although the privacy cases have failed to prevent DOGE’s actions so far, broader claims against the department are beginning to take shape. These new cases may involve concerns that go beyond just data privacy, raising questions about the role and influence of DOGE in government.
The ongoing legal battles could eventually lead to more comprehensive decisions regarding the scope of DOGE’s access and its impact on federal agencies. These lawsuits are still in the early stages, and the full legal consequences of DOGE’s work remain uncertain.
As of now, DOGE continues to operate with relative freedom within various government departments, despite the mounting challenges it faces in the courtroom. The Department of Government Efficiency, under Elon Musk’s leadership, is still navigating the complex legal landscape, which includes concerns about privacy, data security, and its role in government operations.
 can access the Department of Education's data.){kind=link}